Apportioning Liability for Preexisting Conditions to Subsequent Employers in New Jersey Workers’ Comp Claims

Generally speaking, it is very difficult to render subsequent employers liable for the worsening of a preexisting condition. In order to get workers’ compensation under New Jersey’s workers’ comp laws, you or your New Jersey work comp benefit attorney will need to prove that the subsequent employer contributed to your preexisting disability to a material degree. This is not an easy task.

Applying the “Material Degree” Standard

If you were injured in a previous accident that was not related to your current employment, but where the tasks at your current employment worsened or made symptomatic a previous condition that was asymptomatic, you may be entitled to workers’ comp benefits.

However, to successfully claim benefits, your New Jersey work comp benefit attorney will need to demonstrate that an injury at your subsequent (current) employment contributed to your initial disability in a material degree. In other words, there must be some proof of a current work-related injury of condition resulting in permanent disability.

Reasoning For This Standard

An employee is entitled to benefits for an injury that arises out of or during the course of an employment. If you did not suffer from any accidents or occupational diseases from your current employer, the courts are reluctatnt to attach liability to this subsequent employer for a progressive worsening of a preexisting condition.

Successfully Proving the “Material Degree” Standard

To successfully claim workers’ comp benefits from a subsequent employer, your New Jersey work comp benefit attorney will need to provide compelling evidence. More specifically, your attorney will need to:

  • Identify the specific instances of aggravation and include them in your claim as traumatic events in addition to the applicable subsequent occupational claim
  • Hire examining experts to apportion liability
  • Make sure you are properly examined by a doctor upon leaving one for job for another so that a percentage of disability can be identified for purposes of apportionment
  • Look for a measurable worsening of your medical condition as a result of work efforts or other occupational exposure

Contact Us

For more information about getting worker’ compensation benefits from a subsequent employer for the worsening of a preexisting condition, call New Jersey work comp benefit attorney Dan Matrafajlo at -908-248-4404.

Free Case Review

Latest Injury News


A Traumatic Brain Injury Can Change Your Life Forever

September 28, 2017
accident Serious Injuries

Common Accidents That Result in Serious Injuries

June 06, 2015

Congratulations Attorney Dan Matrafajlo's Selection 2015 New Jersey Rising Stars List

April 16, 2015


  • Million Dollar Advocates Forum
  • Superlawyers
  • New jercy association for justice
  • AVVO
  • Cambridge
  • Top 50
  • Cambridge


Free Case Evaluation

Please fill out the following form and we will contact you as soon as possible.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.